Spatial Inequities in Life Expectancy in Small Areas of Buenos Aires, Argentina 2015–2017
Overview3:22CCAI
paperi.ai
0:00 / 0:00
Andrés Trotta, Usama Bilal, Binod Acharya, Harrison S. Quick, Kari Moore, Mónica Serena Perner, Marcio Alazraqui, Ana Diez Roux
Two people can live in the same city yet face dramatically different chances of reaching old age. In Buenos Aires, the neighborhood itself was tied to a gap in life expectancy of nearly fifteen years for men.
Studies of life expectancy (LE) in small areas of cities are relatively common in high-income countries but rare in Latin American countries. Small-area estimation methods can help to describe and quantify inequities in LE between neighborhoods and their predictors. Our objective was to analyze the distribution and spatial patterning of LE across small areas of Ciudad Autónoma de Buenos Aires (CABA), Argentina, and its association with socioeconomic characteristics. As part of the SALURBAL project, we used georeferenced death certificates in 2015–2017 for CABA, Argentina. We used a spatial Bayesian Poisson model using the TOPALS method to estimate age- and sex-specific mortality rates. We used life tables to estimate LE at birth. We obtained data on neighborhood socioeconomic characteristics from the 2010 census and analyzed their associations. LE at birth was higher for women (median of across neighborhoods = 81.1 years) compared to men (76.7 years). We found a gap in LE of 9.3 (women) and 14.9 years (men) between areas with the highest and the lowest LE. Better socioeconomic characteristics A. Trotta (*) · S. M. Perner · M. Alazraqui Institute of Collective Health, National University of Lanus, Buenos Aires, Argentina e-mail: doctortrotta@gmail.com U. Bilal · B. Acharya · H. Quick · K. Moore · A. Diez Roux Urban Health Collaborative, Dornsife School of Public Health, Drexel University, Philadelphia, PA, USA were associated with higher LE. For example, mean differences in LE at birth in areas with highest versus lowest values of composite SES index were 2.79 years (95% CI: 2.30 to 3.28) in women and 5.61 years (95% CI: 4.98 to 6.24) in men. We found large spatial inequities in LE across neighborhoods of a large city in Latin America, highlighting the importance of place-based policies to address this gap. Keywords Life expectancy · Small area estimation · Urban health · Latin America
Transcript
Two people can live in the same city yet face dramatically different chances of reaching old age. In Buenos Aires, the neighborhood itself was tied to a gap in life expectancy of nearly fifteen years for men. Life expectancy in small areas of cities is relatively common to study in high-income countries but rare in Latin American countries.
This study examined how life expectancy was distributed across small areas of Buenos Aires and how it was associated with neighborhood socioeconomic characteristics. The study used death records, population information, and neighborhood socioeconomic information to estimate life expectancy at birth.
The city was divided into geostatistical small areas, each based on an average of about five thousand households, as defined by Argentina’s national statistics institute. The study linked georeferenced death records from twenty fifteen to twenty seventeen to the city’s three hundred fifty-one small areas.
The study also used population information and socioeconomic data from the two thousand ten census to characterize conditions in those small areas. The pattern was geographic: life expectancy was higher in the north and northeast of the city than in the south and southwest.
A higher-life-expectancy strip also ran through the center, surrounded by areas with lower life expectancy. The map therefore revealed a pattern across place, not just a citywide average. In Buenos Aires, expected lifespan depends strongly on where people live: it is generally longer in the north and northeast, while the south and southwest fare worse, with a separate higher-lifespan strip through the center.
This uneven pattern makes neighborhood conditions impossible to ignore. Women had higher life expectancy than men across the city, and that pattern also held when life expectancy was considered at ages twenty, forty, and sixty.
But the bigger surprise was the spread between neighborhoods: the difference between the highest and lowest areas was 9.3 years for women and 14.9 years for men. Education, school attendance, and access to water were linked with higher life expectancy, while unemployment and overcrowding were linked with lower life expectancy.
All of these neighborhood conditions were associated with life expectancy, and the relationships were stronger among men. For education, men in areas with the highest levels had 5.63 more years of life expectancy than men in areas with the lowest levels. The estimates used all registered deaths during the study period and were linked to small areas.
The study could also inform research that includes the wider metropolitan area around Buenos Aires. There was an important limitation: neighborhood conditions came from the two thousand ten census, while deaths came from twenty fifteen to twenty seventeen, so the time difference could bias the results.
Life expectancy was not evenly distributed across Buenos Aires: better education, school attendance, water access, and less unemployment and overcrowding went together with longer lives. Health policy therefore has to improve places, not only individuals.
A derivative work by Paperi · AI-generated script, voice and captions
· pages and figures unaltered
Made with Paperi.
Drop in a research PDF — get a narrated video walkthrough like this one,
with highlights that follow the narration. Free to start.
India is rushing toward artificial intelligence, but the people most affected may not be the people deciding how it is used. This study asks a practical question: how can India spot the risks before they become everyday harm?India is adopting AI at enormous scale, but this study argues that the hardest problem is not simply building better systems. It is identifying whose interests those systems serve, and who may be left out.
A benefit can exist on paper and still feel out of reach. In the Netherlands, parents with more education actually reported lower access to childcare benefits, a result that turns the usual story about inequality upside down.A benefit designed to make childcare affordable can become harder to reach when the application itself is digital, complex, and treated as the parent’s responsibility. This study asks whether literacy helps explain who feels able to access it.
What if a leader angers a powerful foreign partner not by accident, but to prove loyalty to voters back home? This paper argues that a diplomatic backlash can sometimes be politically useful.What if a diplomatic backlash is not a failure, but the point? This paper argues that leaders can trade foreign condemnation for domestic support when the right voters are watching.