A qualitative quantitative mixed methods study of domestic violence against women
Drop in a research PDF — get a narrated video walkthrough like this one, with highlights that follow the narration. Free to start.
Transcript
This study reveals a shocking paradox where higher education and income for women correlate with increased violence scores. It combines hard statistics with the raw, personal stories of nine women in Iran to expose the hidden reality of domestic abuse. Violence against women remains one of the most widespread and persistent human rights violations globally today.
Despite modern communication, most cases go unreported due to fear, stigma, and a culture of silence. This specific study aims to investigate both the prevalence and the lived experiences of this violence in Semnan. Globally, it is estimated that thirty-five percent of women experience physical or sexual violence by a partner in their lifetime.
In Iran specifically, the reported prevalence of domestic violence stands at twenty-two point nine percent. Provinces with high unemployment and poverty rates also show the highest levels of violence against women. To capture the full picture, the researchers used a mixed-methods approach combining cross-sectional descriptive and phenomenological qualitative methods.
For the quantitative part, they surveyed married women using cluster sampling based on health center areas over a year. Qualitatively, they selected nine women who had sought counseling for domestic violence for in-depth interviews. Table 1 provides a detailed sociodemographic profile of the nine participants, listing their ages, educational levels, and occupations alongside those of their husbands.
The data reveals that while most women are housewives, their education ranges from basic literacy to bachelor degrees, and their husbands work in diverse roles such as laborers, welders, or office workers. This breakdown is essential for understanding the specific social contexts and backgrounds of the individuals whose experiences with domestic violence are being analyzed.
The researchers utilized a standard seventy-one item questionnaire developed by Mohseni Tabrizi to measure different types of spousal abuse. Scoring ranges from zero to three hundred, where scores above one hundred and twenty-one indicate severe domestic violence.
Through Colaizzi's seven-step method, the team extracted two hundred and forty-six primary codes from the interview transcripts. These codes were grouped into eighty-five sub-categories, then twenty-three categories, and finally integrated into seven major themes.
Figure 1 maps the complex themes surrounding domestic violence against women, centering on their lived experiences. The authors identify seven key categories radiating from this core, including "Role failure," "Repressors," and "Efforts to preserve the family." By organizing these qualitative findings into a visual framework, the figure highlights how systemic issues like "Inefficient supportive systems" intersect with personal struggles such as "Inappropriate solving of family conflicts.
Table 2 displays the seven major themes and twenty-three specific categories extracted from qualitative interviews regarding family conflict. The authors organized these findings into four primary areas: facilitators, repressors, efforts to preserve the family, and consequences.
This structure highlights how factors like a husband's criminal record or inappropriate age for marriage act as catalysts, while shame and fear often function as repressors that silence victims. Ultimately, the table maps the complex journey of these women, revealing the severe emotional harm and social isolation they face when support systems fail.
In the quantitative phase, three hundred and seventy-six married women participated, with a mean age of thirty-eight point five two years. The age range spanned from eighteen to seventy-three years, with marriage durations varying from one to forty years. When analyzing the severity of violence, sixty point six percent of participants experienced severe violence.
Only twenty-three point seven percent reported low violence, while fifteen point seven percent faced moderate levels. Table 4 presents the correlation coefficients between demographic variables and scores across different domains of violence, such as psychological, economical, physical, and sexual violence.
The authors report that age difference in years shows a positive correlation with all forms of violence, with r-values ranging from 0.43 to 0.47 and p-values less than 0.001. Conversely, the number of children is negatively correlated with these scores, indicating an inverse relationship where higher numbers of children correspond to lower reported violence scores.
Regression analysis revealed that an increase in women's education level independently predicts a higher violence score. Similarly, higher income levels for women also showed a significant relationship with increased violence scores. Table 5 presents a regression analysis identifying two key predictors of violence scores: women's education and women's income.
The data reveals that both variables have statistically significant positive relationships with violence, indicated by p-values of 0.001 for each. Specifically, the unstandardized coefficients show that an increase in these factors corresponds to a rise in the violence score, with values of 3.386 for education and 3.439 for income.
This suggests that within this study's context, higher levels of female education and income are associated with increased reported violence. Patriarchal beliefs rooted in tradition scored the highest among all domains related to domestic violence in this study.
Qualitatively, the normalization of men's anger acts as a repressor preventing women from expressing their suffering. The consequences of this violence extend to children, causing emotional and social harm to the entire family unit. Because divorce is considered a taboo in Iranian culture, fear of humiliation forces many women to remain silent.
The authors conclude that breaking the taboo of domestic violence is necessary to implement effective prevention plans. Promoting divorce as a viable solution after counseling should be implemented seriously to minimize harm to families. The research proves that patriarchal beliefs drive violence across all social classes, while systemic silence prevents women from seeking help.
Breaking these taboos is essential to protect families.